What are differing site conditions in construction?
Differing site conditions are physical conditions at the site, usually below ground or hidden, that differ materially from what the contract documents showed or from what is normally encountered. A differing site conditions clause lets the contractor recover added cost and time, if it gives prompt written notice before disturbing the condition.
How does a differing site condition claim work?
Federal contracts recognize two types under FAR 52.236-2: Type I, conditions that differ materially from those indicated in the contract, and Type II, unknown conditions of an unusual nature that differ from those ordinarily encountered.
Under A201-2017 Section 3.7.4, the party that finds a concealed or unknown condition must notify the other promptly, before the condition is disturbed, and no later than 14 days after first observing it.
Notice is where most claims fail: stop, photograph, notify in writing and wait for direction before removing the evidence.
Where is it in the contract documents?
| Document | Clause | What it says |
|---|---|---|
| FAR | 52.236-2 | Differing site conditions, Type I and Type II |
| AIA A201-2017 | Section 3.7.4 | Concealed or unknown conditions, notice within 14 days |
| Geotechnical report | Contract documents or reference only | Whether the report is a contract document matters for Type I claims |
What does it look like on a project?
Excavating for footings at a Texas medical office, the contractor hits rock at 4 feet where the boring logs in the contract showed clay to 12 feet. It stops work, photographs the trench, gives written notice the same day, and later recovers the added excavation cost and three days.
IllustrativeExample figures, not a real project.
What should you check?
- The clause in your contract, and any owner disclaimers
- Whether the geotechnical report is a contract document
- The notice deadline, often shorter than for other claims
- Daily records and photos before the condition is disturbed
- Whether your subcontracts flow the same rights down
Dora, BAU AI's contract review agent, flags how your contract changes this clause from the AIA base form, cited to the clause and page, for your team and counsel to decide.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between Type I and Type II differing site conditions?
Type I conditions differ from what the contract documents indicated; Type II conditions are unusual and differ from what is normally encountered for that kind of work.
How fast must I give notice?
Before disturbing the condition, and under A201-2017 no later than 14 days after first observing it. Many contracts are stricter.
Can an owner disclaim the geotechnical report?
Many try, by making the report reference-only. That can weaken a Type I claim, so read how the report is classified.
Related
Related terms: construction change directive, waiver of consequential damages, value engineering, flow-down clause, builder's risk insurance.
Sources
- FAR 52.236-2, Differing Site Conditions
- AIA A201-2017, Section 3.7.4
Find this clause in your own contract
Bring one contract or bid package to a 15-minute call. The agents read it with you and cite every finding to its clause and page.